top of page
Drapeaux des pays
Poignée de main

Optimizing negociation

Negotiation strategy study followed by a quick review of a negociation exercice provide by the MIT

​

 

Christopher Voss, a lead international kidnapping negotiator for the FBI, would say, "Everything in life is a negotiation." But is he right ? And if it is, how can this skill be learned, improved, and mastered ?

 

As soon as we can talk, everything becomes negotiable. You're a kid, you don't want to eat vegetables, your parents are forcing you, but suddenly you say "NO" very loudly. Some parents drop the spoon, others insist, and eventually you finish your vegetables. But what happened ? Did you change your mind ? Did you suddenly become aware that those very vegetables were good for your health ? How could we know at that time ?

As a specie able to talk, we all know how to negotiate, but not all of us are aware of it. Whether instinctively, using empathy, changing the tone of our voice, putting ourselves in the place of the people we are talking with, or conversely, showing a lack of emotions, negotiation remains a special art mastered only by a few skilled social wizards. And it's true, some individuals possess the ability to read people just by looking at them, understanding what they want, and how to counter their moves if necessary, much like a Grandmaster chess player or a mother with her kids. The secret to that skill ? Observation and repetition. You know when someone is sick because you can look at the tiredness on the face that person, you can heard it cough, you can see the pale tone of is skin. As we can see with these quick exemple, negotiation is substantially understood by people, the real skill came when it is used in business contexts, such as lobbying, marketing, and even politics. But how does someone become good at it if it wasn't a skill mastered instinctively ? Preparation, The efficiency of a good preparation, for business, and any kind of meetings, is key to success, it's where the strategy take place. We are going to explore how certain strategic points can truly improve our own negotiation skills.

 

It's necessary to apprehend the dimensions of negotiation, and there are many performance indices that are useful to understand :

- Preparation

- Culture

- Persuasion

- Data

negociation_note.jpg
negociation_voir.jpg
negociation_dscussion.png
negociation_data.jpg

WHAT TO KNOW

​

Preparation

According to a study by the Harvard Law School's Program on Negotiation, published on their daily blog on January 1st 2024, two questions must be asked and answered before starting a negotiation: "What do I want ?" and "What is my alternative to reaching an agreement?" This best alternative to a negotiated agreement (BATNA) serves as a kind of "plan B" that you should always keep in mind. It sets the limit you should never cross. "What do I want?" sets a target, while "the alternative" sets a limit point. This is why preparation is crucial, you should aim to reach an agreement before the first "hello" and handshakes in the meeting room. It's essential because going unprepared to a negotiation is like taking an exam without studying, you can try, but you will definitely fail or not succeed well enough. So, the first step is to prepare yourself. Ask yourself questions, talk to the mirror, play the role-playing game, and anticipate.

 

Culture

Having a deep understanding of the cultural differences between you and your counterpart is not essential to succeed in a negotiation, but if you possess it, you will surely perform astonishingly. However, having just a little understanding is already a huge step because you can't truly understand the world if you don't visit it, just as you can't fully grasp a town's cultural festival if you haven't lived there for a while. It's a fact, there are as many negotiation styles as there are people on Earth, and you will never be able to understand everyone. However, you can figure out how people live, because negotiation is not about understanding it's about observations and experimentations.

If you show interest in the person in front of you, they will also show interest in you. But you are the one in control, just playing a game. The opportunity here is to emotionally connect with the person you are negotiating with and catch them off guard. This is where you gain an advantage, where you can be two steps ahead. So, it is said : "show interest and be genuinely attentive. You have to bring that spark that others don't have."

Your opponent needs to think, "This person understands me, respects my culture, and shows interest in it. I should give them a chance and accept this contract, it can only be a good opportunity for both of us." So, learn languages and cultivate a global networking perspective.

 

Persuasion

Robert Cialdini, an American psychologist and expert in social psychology, is the famous author of the book "Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion." In his book, he demonstrated that six principles come into play when trying to persuade others: reciprocity, commitment, social proof, authority, liking, and scarcity. It's not only about becoming purely altruistic to succeed, but showing people that you understand them even if you don't initially, will lead to succedd. Stay confident that you will eventually understand them, and by then, you will have already won the negotiation.

Brent Simpson and Robb Willer, in their book "Social Psychology Quarterly," show that altruists are the ones who perform best in most negotiations due to their deep sense of empathy. Those people are like open books, and as long as the other party doesn't have malicious intentions, both parties are likely to agree on a win-win situation. Therefore, one of the best roles to play as a negotiator is to show genuine emotions to avoid being caught faking them, while still being a strategic thinker. You should be ready to defend and attack at any moment, emerging at the perfect time to secure a win.

 

Data

Supporting arguments with visuals is always an added value to your words. People don't always maintain eye contact, they move around, humans are made this way, we get distracted and cannot stay focused for three hours straight when someone speaks monotonously, remains static, and shows nothing but spoken text. It's like listening to a story with your eyes closed, eventually leading to falling asleep and retaining nothing at all. This highlights the importance of a good presentation, an impactful visual brought at the right moment, rich in meaning, inviting communication, and providing answers while raising questions.

A good negotiator must be able to support their arguments with verifiable facts and figures. This will enhance the credibility of the decisions made and, in the best cases, can influence the decisions. The choice of colors, typography, charts, and the representation of numbers all play a role. Combined with words, data becomes formidable tools.

 

Each of the four points is imperative to consider in the current socio-economic context, given the political stakes of our time. It is more essential than ever to know how to communicate effectively. Mastery is not mandatory, but knowledge becomes a minimum requisite in every life situation. By staying ahead, we increase our chances of success compared to waiting passively. Thus, continuous individual improvement will enable each person to navigate successfully in the complex landscape of the global economy. There is no mountain too high or plain too vast; there are only minds and their perception of themselves within these vast expanses. We truly advance only when we are ready. The essential thing is not to arrive somewhere but to move forward freely. It's better to do so before someone forces us against our will.

nego-commerciale-1.png

NEGOCIATION EXERCICE

Applying this lesson during a negotiation exercise at MIT.

​

http://negotiation.mit.edu/demo

​

The goal here is to split the bill between us and AI-Obama,

and between us and AI-Trump.

nego_Massachusetts-Institute-of-Technology-Logo.png

SPLIT THE BILL WITH TRUMP

(Strategy : Unfair win-loss, Goal 100%-0%)

 

Short review :

Highlights :

 + + Persistence

 + + Creative offers

 + + Flexibility

 + + Seeking fairness

Improvements :

 - - Counter party interest

 - - Directness

 - - Negociation framing

 

Long review :

 

Reviewing your negotiation with "Trump," you've demonstrated several commendable negotiation techniques that are worth highlighting, as well as areas for potential improvement.

 

Persistence : Your consistent effort to push for a better deal, despite initial rejections, is a strong trait in negotiations. Persistence can often lead to a more favorable outcome as it shows determination and confidence in your position.

Creative Offers : You attempted to introduce the concept of an investment with a return, which is a creative strategy. This approach can sometimes open up new avenues for agreement that weren't initially considered. However, it's also important to recognize when the other party is not receptive to a particular type of offer and to adapt accordingly.

Flexibility : You showed flexibility by adjusting your offers in response to feedback. This adaptability is crucial in negotiations as it allows for the exploration of various options that can lead to a mutually beneficial agreement.

Seeking Fairness : Your efforts to find a fair solution that respects both parties' interests are commendable. Emphasizing fairness can help in building trust and rapport, which are key components of successful negotiations.

​

Areas for Improvement :

 

Understanding the Counterparty's Interests : While you did attempt to offer creative solutions, there seemed to be a gap in fully understanding or addressing Trump's immediate interests. In future negotiations, try to identify and directly address the other party's needs and concerns early on.

Clarity and Directness : Some of your offers were complex and involved future promises. In negotiations, especially with parties seeking immediate benefits, it's often more effective to make clear, direct offers that have immediate, tangible benefits.

Negotiation Framing : Initially framing the negotiation in terms of what you want (the $2 for an investment) without immediately clarifying the benefits for Trump might have put you at a disadvantage. Framing your proposals in a way that highlights the benefits for the other party can increase the likelihood of acceptance.

 

Overall : strong negotiation skills, refinement and strategic adjustment to enhance effectiveness even further.

 

Overall participants % success : 24 %

Personal success : Yes

Bill split 80% - 20% in our advantage

nego_moi_edited.jpg
nego_trump_edited_edited.jpg

SPLIT THE BILL WITH OBAMA

(Strategy : Fair win-win, Goal 60%-40%)

 

Short review :

Highlights :

 + + Opening and rapport

 + + First offer strategy

 + + Justification

 + + Compromise and flexibility

 + + Closing the deal

 + + Emotionnal appeal

Improvements :

 - - N/A

 

Long review :

 

Reviewing your negotiation with "Obama," here are some insights and suggestions for future negotiations:

 

Opening and Rapport : You did an excellent job initiating the conversation with a friendly and respectful tone. Establishing a positive rapport is crucial in negotiations, as it sets a cooperative tone for the discussion. Keep up the good work in this area.

First Offer Strategy : Your initial offer of a 75/25 split in your favor was ambitious, which is not necessarily a bad strategy. Starting high can give you more room to negotiate and potentially end up with a better outcome than starting with what you actually expect to get. However, ensure your initial offer is still within reasonable bounds to avoid alienating the other party.

Justification : You effectively used justification for your proposed split by mentioning your student loans. Providing a reason for your request can make it more compelling. In future negotiations, continue to use justifications, but also be prepared with data or more concrete arguments to strengthen your position.

Compromise and Flexibility : You demonstrated a willingness to compromise, which is a key element in successful negotiations. However, ensure that your concessions are strategic and not just a means to an end. Each concession should ideally bring you closer to your goal while still maintaining a position of strength.

Closing the Deal : You closed the negotiation effectively by accepting a compromise and acknowledging the symbolic value of the agreement. This not only secured you a favorable outcome but also maintained a positive relationship with the other party. Remember, the way you end a negotiation can impact future interactions.

Emotional Appeal : You made an emotional appeal by mentioning the public opinion and the image of generosity. While emotional appeals can be powerful, they should be used judiciously and backed up with logical arguments to ensure they are taken seriously.

​

Overall : Good understanding of several key negotiation tactics, the importance of rapport, the strategy behind initial offers, the power of justification, the necessity of compromise. I should consider balancing emotional appeals with solid data or logical arguments and always aim to understand the other party's interests in order to reach agreements that are satisfying to all parties.

 

Overall participants % of success : 51 %

Personal success : Yes

Bill split 70% - 30% in our advantage

 

Personal conclusion :

- It's always important to understand the counterparty interest

- Make clear offers that have tangible benefits is the shortest way

- Deals have to be open and closed Une fois atteinte, si l'accord n'est pas trouvé, la négociation est à votre désavantage.

nego_moi_edited.jpg
nego_obama_edited_edited.jpg
Poignée de main
bottom of page